Skip to content
Sunday, November 8, 2026
Summit Marketing Blog

South Africa Coach Claims Team Receives Unfair Treatment in Recent Red Card Incidents

Rugby match action
South Africa lock Franco Mostert was sent off after 12 minutes in the recent victory over Italy

Springboks assistant coach Mzwandile Stick contends that the world champions have faced biased treatment following sending-off episodes during their wins against France and Italy.

Suspension Decisions Provoke Controversy

Lood de Jager was handed a four-match ban after receiving a red card for a high tackle on France back player Thomas Ramos in Paris, while Mostert was shown a straight red card for a high contact on Italy's Paolo Garbisi in the Italian city.

Mostert faces a international rugby governing body disciplinary hearing in the coming days, with Stick revealing that the world champions have lodged an appeal against De Jager's suspension.

"Every week we are losing players and it's disappointing," Stick told journalists in Dublin before South Africa's Test against Ireland on Saturday.

Growing Concerns About Equitable Officiating

He stated: "I don't want to make statements and then end up also being banned like Rassie [Erasmus, head coach] in the past.

"We've never talked bad about opposing sides. We always try and play in a positive manner, and ideally things can just be on the field. Do you believe we are treated justly? In my opinion so."

Stick also pointed to recently imposed bans for Springbok players Makazole Mapimpi and Jan-Hendrik Wessels while playing for their club teams in the domestic competition.

  • Outside back Mapimpi received a five-week ban for a illegal challenge on the Irish province's Michael Lowry on October 18th
  • Forward Wessels is serving an eight-match ban - reduced from nine - for an reported genital grab on the provincial team's Josh Murphy

Pattern of Suspensions Creates Doubts

"When examining at the past four sendings-off with our players - we had Makazole Mapimpi suspended, who is not with the squad at the present time," said Stick.

"This player is on 47 international appearances, missed out on a tour to reach to the fiftieth cap. Jan-Hendrik Wessels, a youngster, also was excluded. Suspended.

"Lood de Jager, which I feel after this weekend and all that I've observed, even the Fijian team and the France game, the ruck clearances that were there, the Irish game against the Wallabies, incidents that were even worse than what these players have been banned for.

"Then for them they're suspended, but opposition players will return and play this week. Surely in some way, this is unjust.

"In my view we merit this as a team. We're making every effort in our powers to make sure that we send the right message when it comes to how we play the game."

Physical Nature of the Sport

Coach speaking to media
Stick addressed reporters in the Irish capital on Monday before the Springboks' international match against Ireland on Saturday

Mostert was dismissed in the early stages against the Italian team, a contest the Springboks won 32-14.

"If you look at the conduct of Franco Mostert and Lood de Jager the previous week, he has done everything by the rules," commented backs coach Stick.

"His only error was just maybe the contact was here [chest] but it ended up in the head. It's unclear how does that become permanent red card.

"In our view as technical staff, we must continue to put in effort because we're coaching these guys. We can observe that they're physically imposing. They try to follow all instructions by the rules, but because rugby is a physical game, occasionally you cannot execute perfect.

"When officials to declare the tackle was 'never legal', it's frustrating."

Match Officiating Under Scrutiny

Stick also asserted the majority of the decisions against Italy did not go South Africa's way.

"Probably about twenty-one rulings that were meant to be made in the opening period or perhaps the initial three quarters, twenty decisions were against us.

"Not due of the ref. Unfortunately he has to respect the comms from his support staff off the field.

"Frustrated with it, but once again, I feel for Italy and I would like to express regret with how events unfolded, because they've got a good coaching staff and then their players were also prepared for the match, but for external factors to happen like that, I don't think they deserve what they've got in that game."

By

James Newton

A digital strategist with over a decade of experience in helping startups scale through innovative marketing campaigns.

Summit Marketing Blog

Type to search articles.